Skip to Content

Sour Milk Gingerbread Recipe from 1869

(Affiliate disclosure: I may receive a commission if you purchase something through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying puchases. See more details here:)

Slice of sour milk gingerbread with icing on a china plate with pink and purple flowers.

Since I’ve become a raw milk convert I finally have a source of true sour milk to use in old recipes. What was left of the most recent gallon of raw milk that I had just went sour. Even though sour raw milk is still perfectly safe to drink, the sour taste and smell isn’t exactly very appealing, not to me anyways. Maybe it’s an acquired taste. For now, though, I definitely prefer the sweet flavor of fresh raw milk.

What to do with Raw Milk that’s Gone Sour?

Even though I don’t care to drink raw milk that has gone sour, it’s perfect for using in baking. That’s one of the many benefits of raw milk – when it sours, it’s still perfectly useful unlike pasteurized milk which needs to be poured down the drain once it’s spoiled.

It’s pretty rare to find a recipe that uses sour milk in any modern cookbook, unless it’s something like Nourishing Traditions of course. If you look in any cookbook or recipe pamphlet from the 1800s or earlier, though, you’ll most likely find several recipes that call for sour milk. Sour milk was much more common in the days before pasteurized milk became the norm and in the days before refrigeration when milk soured much more quickly, especially in the summertime.

I’ve tried a couple of unsuccessful sour milk recipes in the past few months since I started drinking raw milk. They weren’t failures because of the sour milk itself but because of my own misinterpretations of the 19th century recipes. 19th century recipes are easy to mess up because they usually give very little in the way of actual instructions for how to use the ingredients. I guess back then it was assumed that anyone using the recipes would know what to do with the ingredients. So, because I’ve had a few sour milk baking failures, I was pretty excited when I found a recipe that actually worked!

The recipe I found was for a sour milk gingerbread cake. I know I’m about four months too early for gingerbread since it’s a traditional Christmas dessert, but I was really craving some anyways. I love gingerbread at any time of the year, especially a soft gingerbread cake. Gingerbread cookies are great too, but the cake version is the best in my opinion. This is the recipe I found:

Original Sour Milk Gingerbread Recipe from 1869:

The recipe that I found was called “Cathie’s Gingerbread” and it was from Mrs. Winslow’s Domestic Receipt Book for 1869.

Note: Mrs. Winslow’s Domestic Receipt Book was a recipe pamphlet designed to advertise Mrs. Winslow’s Soothing Syrup for babies – a syrup that actually contained morphine as it’s main ingredient and was sadly associated with infant deaths during this time period. The use of morphine was common in patent medications of the time, and it was also unfortunately quite common for those taking patent medications to have little or no knowledge of the ingredients that those “medicines” contained. Many mothers would have given this syrup to their babies without having any idea that it could end up being addictive or even fatal.

There are many good recipes in the Mrs. Winslow’s Domestic Receipt Books and they were most likely collected from bakers who had no knowledge of the potential harms of the soothing syrup. Because of that fact, I am leaving this recipe up for those who may have viewed it previously and would like to make it again. In the future, though, if I ever try another old-fashioned sour milk gingerbread recipe that doesn’t have such a sad and controversial history, I will add an update here.

This is the text of the original recipe:

“One cup brown sugar, one cup butter, four eggs, one cup sour milk, two teaspoons soda, one tablespoon ginger. Flour to mix soft as cake. Bake in a modrate oven.”

This Is My Modern Adaptation of the Sour Milk Gingerbread

  • 1/2 cup whole cane sugar
  • 1/2 cup molasses
  • 1 cup (2 sticks) butter
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 cup sour milk
  • 2 teaspoons baking soda
  • 1 Tbs. ginger
  • 1 1/2 cups whole wheat flour
  • 1 1/2 cups unbleached all-purpose flour (or additional whole wheat flour if you prefer using all whole wheat.)

Directions: Preheat oven to 350 degrees and grease and flour a 13 x 9 inch baking pan. For the best results and a lighter cake, let the eggs and milk sit out on the counter until they reach room temperature before using them. Melt the butter and pour it into your mixing bowl. Then add the brown sugar, the molasses, and the ginger and stir until combined. Beat the eggs lightly and add them to the mixture, stirring again until combined. Dissolve the baking soda into the cup of sour milk. Once the baking soda is fully dissolved, add the milk to the batter and stir again. Add the three cups of flour and stir until all of the ingredients are fully incorporated. Pour the batter into the pan and bake at 350 degrees for 30 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.

Optional: I drizzled a bit of icing over my cake because it looks so much prettier that way and because icing lets you feel like you’re being indulgent without the complete sugar-high that comes with a true frosting. I didn’t actually measure out the ingredients I used for the icing, but basically I just put a little powdered sugar in a bowl, added about a teaspoonful of maple syrup, a few drops of pure lemon extract, and a little bit of pure vanilla extract (probably about a 1/2 teaspoon.) Then I just added a few drops of water and stirred and added a few more drops and stirred again until it was the right consistency for drizzling.

Recipe Analysis: This cake is surprisingly light for a cake made with from whole wheat flour. Most whole wheat flour cakes end up being pretty dry and heavy, but this cake has a very nice texture. Maybe it’s the sour milk that makes the difference? Or maybe it’s the molasses? Whatever it is, I was pleasantly surprised by the texture. The flavor is great, too – sweet without being sickeningly sweet and subtly gingery without being overpowering. In fact, the next time I make this, I might even add a bit more ginger because I like my gingerbread to be sufficiently spicy. This cake would be great for experimenting with different spice combinations too – cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, mace, cloves – I think any and all of those would be delicious with this cake.

Notes:

  • If you don’t have raw milk that’s already sour, you can just leave your raw milk out on the counter until it sours. Or, if you only have regular pasteurized milk available, you can add a spoonful of vinegar to the milk.
  • I decided to substitute molasses for some of the brown sugar in the recipe since molasses is less of a processed and refined food than regular sugar is. A half cup of refined sugar is better than a whole cup. If you’re feeling adventurous, though, you could experiment with using all molasses and no brown sugar. When I’ve done this in the past, the end result has been kind of sticky, but there might be a way to play around with the ingredients to keep that from happening. For now, though, I’m content with just reducing the refined sugar. Everything in moderation anyways, right?

Well, it might not be the Christmas season quite yet, but I’m ready for some good old-fashioned sour milk gingerbread! I think I’ll go have another piece right now . . .

Banner to click to subscribe for blog newsletter for old-fashioned simple living tips.
Slice of sour milk gingerbread with icing on a china plate with pink and purple flowers.

This post is linked to Make Your Move Monday at Simply Made Home, Scratch Cookin’ Tuesday at Granny’s Vital Vittles, Hearth and Soul at Elsa Cooks, and Food on Friday at Carole’s Chatter.

(We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.)

The information in this post is not to be taken as medical advice and is not intended to diagnose or treat any disease.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Rodney

Wednesday 17th of August 2022

I Tried this recipe and it turned out great. I Used a little more of the ingredients because I wanted a Deeper bread/Cake and Baked it in a deep Glass baking dish which made the bottom crunchy delicious. I Added a teaspoon of cinnamon , dash of cloves and a Dash of nutmeg. It's very delicious. Next time I may try it without the extra spices and the teaspoon of vanilla extract.

Lori Elliott

Thursday 18th of August 2022

I'm glad to hear that the recipe turned out well for you, and it's always great when the bottom gets a nice caramelized crunch to it!

Carole

Friday 11th of January 2013

Lori, thank you for linking this in to Food on Friday. We are now getting a great collection of dishes using ginger together. I hope you have stopped by some of the other links to check them out!

Ps I have just signed up to follow your blog. A follow back to Carole's Chatter would be wonderful – or have you already followed? Cheers

Ps If you would like email reminders of future Food on Fridays, just pop by and comment and include your email - I won't publish it - and the reminder will be by bcc so it will remain private

Lori

Friday 11th of January 2013

Thanks for following, Carole! I'm following you now too :)

Carole

Thursday 10th of January 2013

Hi there. Food on Friday: Ginger is open for entries. This looks like a good one! I do hope you link it in. This is the link . Please do pop back to check out some of the other links. Happy New Year!

Lori

Thursday 10th of January 2013

Hi, Carole, thanks for letting me know about the link-up! I'm on my way over there now :) And happy New Year to you too!

linda @ Axiom at Home

Wednesday 12th of December 2012

This recipe sounds really great. I am going to give it a try next time I found myself with soured raw milk. :) Have you tried coconut sugar in place of the brown sugar? I think I may give that substitution a try. I really love your old-fashioned recipes. :)

Lori

Thursday 20th of December 2012

Awesome! Glad it turned out well for you! :)

linda @ Axiom at Home

Thursday 20th of December 2012

I did end up making this - I subbed coconut sugar for the brown sugar, one cup almond flour for one cup spelt, and I was low on ginger! So, only 1/2 tbsp. Anyway, it turned out fantastic. Just really really good. What a great recipe. Thank you. Next time I'll add more ginger though :)

Lori

Friday 14th of December 2012

I've haven't tried it with coconut sugar, but I bet it would be delicious! I recently found a source for organic whole cane sugar, so I've been using that in place of brown sugar since the whole cane sugar is less refined.

mrsdull

Saturday 18th of August 2012

I love these old recipes! Thanks for sharing it with us at Scratch Cookin'Tuesday!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.