Skip to Content

Traditional Holiday Dessert Recipes from the 1800s

(Affiliate disclosure: I may receive a commission if you purchase something through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See more details here:)

A collage of pictures of holiday dessert recipes with text in the center that says "Traditional Holiday Dessert Recipes from the 1800s."

If you are looking to have an old-fashioned Thanksgiving or Christmas celebration this year, one of the best ways to accomplish that is through the food on your holiday table. One of my favorite ways to capture the feeling of an old-fashioned holiday is through traditional dessert recipes, whether they are desserts that are still popular today such as gingerbread and pumpkin pie or whether they are less common desserts such as fruitcake and plum pudding.

The recipes that I have included in this list are all ones from authentic antique cookbooks from the 1800s (and one that comes from the late 1700s). Many of these recipes are ones that we would normally associate with Christmas today, but these desserts were also very popular at Thanksgiving time in the past.

Three of the recipes on this list are pies, and pie was a very popular part of holiday tables in the past. Gingerbread was very common in the 1800s for both holidays and for everyday use, and recipes with dried fruits such as plum pudding, mincemeat, and fruitcake were considered rich desserts for special occasions.

If you want a truly old-fashioned holiday experience this year, give one of these historic recipes a try!

Traditional Holiday Dessert Recipes from the 1800s

These old-fashioned recipes are all authentic recipes from antique cookbooks from the 19th century (and one from the late 18th century). Even though we associate many of these recipes with Christmas today, these desserts are ones that would have been popular desserts at Thanksgiving or at other holidays back in the 1800s, too.

A collage of pictures of holiday dessert recipes with text in the center that says "Traditional Holiday Dessert Recipes from the 1800s."

(Lori Elliott is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.)

The information in this post is not to be taken as medical advice and is not intended to diagnose or treat any disease.