(Affiliate disclosure: I may receive a commission if you purchase something through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See more details here:)

When you read things online about healthy living, one of the topics that comes up often is the health benefits of seasonal eating. And you sometimes hear the idea that our ancestors only ever ate seasonally and they only ate what was actually growing in their local area. And, while I believe that there are a lot of good things about eating with the seasons and following seasonal rhythms throughout the year, I think it's actually a myth that our ancestors ate seasonally all the time.
I'm not saying that people didn't eat in a way that aligned with the seasons in the past because of course they did. In general, people's diets would have shifted throughout the year in a way that would have matched with the current season that they were experiencing. What I'm saying, though, is that when you actually look at the history of food storage and food preservation, you don't see people eating exclusively seasonal foods.
Food Preservation Throughout History
While there may have been some people in the past who only ate what they could forage or hunt that was available in each specific season, there were a lot of people throughout history who took advantage of different methods of food preservation that allowed them to eat foods that were grown in the warmer months of the year during the season of the year when it was too cold for crops to grow.
Drying foods was one of the main ways that people preserved food in the past, including foods like grains (wheat, rye, barely, corn, etc.) legumes like shelled beans and peas, and fruits. Meat was also sometimes dried to preserve it and allow it to keep for longer.
When you look at recipes from old cookbooks, there are also lots of instructions for preserving fruits and vegetables as jams, pickles, catsup, and shrub syrups for drinks. And many of these recipes pre-date the invention of canning, so these aren't just modern methods of food preservation either. Fresh milk from the spring and summer months was also made into butter and cheeses that could last for many months with the proper storage conditions.
And even going back to Bible times in the book of Genesis you see Joseph storing up grain in Egypt to prepare for the 7 years of famine. And there are mentions of raisins in the Bible, too, so people were drying fruits to preserve them even back then.
It's More About the Balance
I think the difference between the past and now is probably more about the balance between seasonal and out-of-season foods that a person would eat. It's not so much a matter of avoiding all out-of-season foods as it is about having a larger proportion of seasonal foods so that the majority of the diet matches the current season.
In our modern day, for example, it's perfectly normal for someone to have out-of-season foods at every meal and to have lots of fresh summer fruits and vegetables even in January like fruit smoothies with fresh berries and tropical fruits, big salads with tomatoes and cucumbers, etc.
200 years ago, though, out-of-season foods might have been used more like condiments or as small side elements to a meal most of the time rather than being a main part of a meal (with the exception of grains and legumes because breads and other baked goods and legumes like beans and peas were staples in a lot of peoples' diets in the past.)
Someone living in a cold climate 200 hundred years ago might have had a little bit of raspberry jam spread on some biscuits or maybe some pickled vegetables as a side dish or some tomato catsup to give flavor to a meal in January. But they wouldn't have had a big salad with lots of fresh vegetables or a smoothie full of summer berries.
The overall balance of the diets of people living in the past would have leaned more toward seasonal foods with lots of fresh produce and more cooling, raw foods in the summer months and more hearty, warming foods and root vegetables in the colder months of the year. There would have been definite changes with each season as new foods became available or as some foods became less available. But there also would have been some preserved foods grown in different parts of the year that were included in their diets year-round.
Living In Rhythm With the Seasons
I think it's true that people in the past generally ate with the seasons. But I think it's taking it a little bit too far to say that our ancestors only ate seasonal foods because when you look at the history, you actually see a lot of food preservation happening and people finding ways to save their harvests for the months when nothing would be growing.
Our ancestors living in northern climates certainly weren't buying fresh tomatoes at the grocery store in January, but they weren't exactly eating strictly seasonal foods either. They had diets that would change with the different seasons, but they also made use of methods to preserve foods for the times of year when nothing much would grow.
This sort of seasonal rhythm rather than strict seasonal eating is something that I like to try to incorporate into my diet. Some of it happens very intuitively because I find that I lose interest in having a lot of raw, cooling foods in the winter season because I gravitate more towards warmer, heartier foods naturally.
I like to generally try to eat the foods that are in season near where I live, but I also don't hesitate to eat some out-of-season preserved foods either. While I don't find raw tomatoes from the grocery store to be very appealing in the middle of winter, having a jar of spaghetti sauce is one way that I would use an out-of-season food that was preserved for later. And I don't buy fresh strawberries or raspberries at the grocery store during the winter, but I would enjoy having a little bit of strawberry or raspberry jam made from summer fruits.
I feel like seasonal eating is something that works best when we approach it from a place of balance rather than rigidly trying to follow it to the letter and that when we eat seasonally in a balanced way it can be a very enjoyable way to live in rhythm with the changing seasons and to enjoy all of the different foods that each time of the year has to offer.

(Lori Elliott is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.)
The information in this post is not to be taken as medical advice and is not intended to diagnose or treat any disease.

