Sweetened and Dried Tomato Fig Recipe from 1845

(Affiliate disclosure: I may receive a commission if you purchase something through links in this post. Your cost stays the same. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying puchases. See more details here:)

Dried tomatoes on plate with green checked cloth and small pear-shaped tomatoes scattered around

This recipe for sweetened, dried tomato figs is an unusual way to preserve tomatoes that I’ve seen mentioned in several old 19th century cookbooks . Despite the name, there aren’t actually any figs in this recipe at all, but the dried tomatoes do somewhat resemble figs in both appearance and taste. 

In the 19th century as tomatoes were gaining in popularity in America, you start to see more and more recipes (or receipts) using tomatoes in 19th century cookbooks, including recipes for ketchups, sauces, and dried tomato figs. For making tomato figs, small tomatoes are simmered in sugar and then dried fully and coated in more sugar for storage. 

I’m not quite sure if the original intention of the tomato figs was to create a more economical way to make a substitute for dried figs (like with using citron melon to make candied citron for fruitcake rather than buying imported citron fruit) or if someone preserved tomatoes this way and then decided that they happened to look and taste reminiscent of dried figs. Either way, though, they really do remind me of figs and they’re certainly an interesting way to preserve an abundance of fresh tomatoes.

The most popular type of tomato to use for making tomato figs were small pear-shaped tomatoes that were either red or yellow, and you sometimes see the red pear-shaped tomatoes referred to as “fig tomatoes” in 19th century descriptions. 

You can sometimes find yellow or red pear tomato seedlings at garden centers or farm stands, and you can find seeds online too. But if you don’t have pear-shaped tomatoes you could use any small cherry tomato variety. They might not look as much like figs, but the flavor should be pretty similar. 

These are some of the small pear-shaped tomatoes I grew in my garden this summer:

Red and yellow pear shaped tomatoes on green checked cloth

The recipe I’m using comes from The New England Economical Housekeeper from 1845. This is the description of the original recipe:

“Take six pounds of sugar to one peck (or sixteen pounds) of the fruit. Scald and remove the skin of the fruit in the usual way. Cook them over a fire, their own juice being sufficient without the addition of water, until the sugar penetrates and they are clarified. They are then taken out, spread on dishes, flattened, and dried in the sun. A small quantity of the sirup  should be occasionally sprinkled over them whilst drying; after which, pack them down in boxes, treating each layer with powdered sugar. The sirup is afterwards concentrated and bottled for use. They keep well from year to year, and retain surprisingly their flavor, which is nearly that of the best quality of fresh figs. The pear-shaped or single tomatoes answer the purpose best. Ordinary brown sugar may be used, a large portion of which is retained in sirup.” ~ The New England Economical Housekeeper, page 66

I used much smaller amount of tomatoes than what the original recipe calls for because sixteen pounds of tomatoes would make quite a lot! I decided to use brown sugar like the recipe mentions, but I dried mine in the oven rather than drying them out in the sun because I didn’t want to have to worry about ants crawling on them and flies landing on them, etc. because all of the sugary syrup seems like it would be a bug magnet. It was also cloudy on the days I was making my tomato figs, so using the oven was more convenient than waiting for the sun to come back again. 

If you have a dehydrator, you could certainly use that to try them, or if you just have an oven, you could put it on the lowest setting possible and leave the door propped open. Since the oven that I used doesn’t go any lower than 170 degrees, what I did was to turn the oven on and then shut it off when the temperature reached about 110 degrees and then put my tray of tomato figs in to dry. And then when the oven cooled down again, I turned it on again to 110 degrees and shut if off, and kept repeating the process until they were fully dry. 

Once the tomatoes are fully dry, the original recipe calls for storing them in layers with powdered sugar in between. And as I just recently learned from an interpreter at Old Sturbridge Village, the 19th century term “powdered sugar” isn’t the same as the confectioner’s sugar that we refer to as powdered sugar today. In the 19th century, sugar the texture of confectioner’s sugar would have been called “pounded sugar.” Since sugar was typically sold in cones and cooks would need to snip off a piece of the sugar and then use a mortar and pestle to grind the sugar, making a powdery textured confectioner’s sugar would have been quite a bit of work! 

Since this adapted recipe makes just a small batch, you could skip the step of coating them in sugar if you are planning on finishing them up quickly. This adapted recipe makes about 20 dried tomato pieces, but if you want a larger batch you could easily double it to make more.

Dried tomatoes on plate with green checked cloth and small pear-shaped tomatoes scattered around

Sweetened, Dried Tomato Fig Recipe from 1845

Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 45 minutes

These sweetened and dried tomato figs are an unusual way to preserve fresh tomatoes, and they resemble dried figs in both appearance and flavor with a blend of sweetness and tartness. They are a very simple recipe with just two ingredients - tomatoes and brown sugar.

Ingredients

  • About 20 small pear-shaped or cherry tomatoes
  • 3/4 cup brown sugar

Instructions

  1. Let a pot of water come to a simmer on the stove and drop the tomatoes into the water for a minute or two. Then remove the tomatoes with a slotted spoon and let them cool. Once they are cool enough to touch, you can remove the skin of the tomatoes by peeling it off. If it is hard to peel at all, you can simply drop the tomato back into the simmering water for another minute or two and try again.
  2. Once the skins are all removed, put the tomatoes into a small pot and add 3/4 of a cup of brown sugar.
  3. Let the tomatoes simmer in the sugar for about 30 minutes or so. The tomatoes and sugar will create plenty of liquid so there is no need to add any extra water to them.
  4. Once the tomatoes have cooked for around 30 minutes, they will have an appearance that is a bit more see-through. This will be less noticeable if you use brown sugar, though, than if you use white sugar.
  5. Use a spoon to remove the tomatoes from the syrup and spread them out on a baking sheet that has parchment paper spread on it.
  6. Dry the tomatoes fully in a dehydrator, in the oven, or in the sun.
  7. If you're planning to store the tomatoes for a while, you can coat them in a layer of additional sugar. (But since this is such a small batch, you may end up just eating them all relatively quickly!)

Notes

I didn't include any specifics for the amount of time it takes to dry the tomatoes because it really depends on several different factors like the method you use to dry them (oven, dehydrator, sun) and the temperature and humidity levels, etc. I dried mine over a couple of days because I turned the oven off and on when it was convenient (shutting if off overnight and when I was leaving the house, etc.) so it wasn't one continuous amount of time that I was drying them for.

Dried tomatoes on plate with green checked cloth and small pear-shaped tomatoes scattered around

(We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.)

The information in this post is not to be taken as medical advice and is not intended to diagnose or treat any disease.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.